Why Useless?

Useless is better than useful since knowledge which is desirable for its own sake is better than knowledge which is desirable for the sake of something else.

This points out the appropriate goal, but in practice the actual content of this blog will be determined by the whim of its author, as is customary in this genre. Of course it is even more customary to start a blog and then stop forever after a post or two. It is perfectly possible that this will be the case here as well.

6 thoughts on “Why Useless?

  1. I’ve been thinking about useless things lately, and if you’ll forgive me for inquiring into topics you haven’t written about in a long time, I wonder if you could help me with some questions.

    Useless things are things done for their own sake. But we have a habit of comparing and contrasting useless things, and saying that some are better than others (say, styles of music). But to say that something is better than another seems to imply that there is an end that both are directed toward, the better being the one that more readily attains that end. But if both things are useless, there is no such end by definition, as their ends are in themselves,

    So, can useless things not be compared, i.e. all have the “same” goodness? Or, is there really only one -truly- useless thing (happiness, or God, or the Good and Best), and all other things are partly good-in-themselves, and partly means-to-an-end (and are compared by reference to that end)? Or is there a genuine way to compare goodness between two distinct, actually useless things?

    Like

    • The way to think about this not that useless things (in our present sense) have no final cause, but that the final cause is internal. Nonetheless, it is not the same as the thing in every respect, otherwise it could not be a cause at all. So it is typically some aspect of that thing. This could be an aspect that it has in common with something else, so if one of them has it to a greater degree than the other, it will be “better,” by having more of the final cause, that is, more reason to do it.

      St. Augustine holds the “only one truly useless thing” and this amounts approximately to the same thing, namely that “goodness itself” is the aspect that is ultimately intrinsic and that you compare between things.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s